Article
Article name Comparative analysis of national marketing management systems of enterprises
Authors Kalynychenko M.. ,
Bibliographic description
Category Economics
DOI 658.8:338 (477)
DOI 10.21209/2227-­9245-­2018-­24-­5-106-117
Article type Scientific
Annotation The article presents the results of a comparative analysis of national marketing management systems for industrial enterprises. For this purpose, a methodology for such an analysis was developed, including a number of principles and methodological recommendations for implementing the developed algorithm. The set of characteristics (parameters) on which the national systems of marketing management of industrial enterprises were compared was chosen. The systems of marketing management of enterprises are elements of higher-level systems (macromarketing), therefore, the role and place of the state in forming the marketing environment in the US, Japan, China, in the European and post-Soviet countries, as well as the level of centralization / decentralization, formalization / regulation, stability / variability, openness / isolation of national economies. Comparative analysis of the systems of marketing management of industrial enterprises (micromarketing) was conducted on such criteria as marketing philosophy, the main directions of marketing orientation, priorities in marketing management, key success factors in marketing, orientation objects or participants in the marketing process, the result of marketing and enterprise management, the criterion for success in marketing. The general characteristic of national models of marketing management is established: the ideas and marketing philosophy originated in the USA were borrowed and reinterpreted, and after adaptation under the influence of a number of factors their transformation took place with the identification of specific features. It has also been established that the specific practice of developing national systems of the MUPP in a given country is conditioned by objective and subjective factors. A direct relationship between the role of the state in regulating the economy and the effectiveness of enterprise marketing management systems is defined. The use of foreign experience of marketing management by domestic industrial enterprises is impossible without its adaptation and carrying out a deep restructuring of the management systems themselves
Key words marketing management; industrial enterprise; comparative analysis; system; management; options; characteristic; methodology; restructuring; experience in marketing management
Article information Kalynychenko M. Comparative analysis of national marketing management systems of enterprises // Transbaikal State University Journal, 2018, vol. 24, no. 5, pp. 106-117
References 1. Aleshina I. Sovremenny menedzhment: problemy, gipotezy, issledovaniya, NIU-VShE (Modern management: problems, hypotheses, research, NRU-HSE). Available at : https://refdb.ru/look/3953537.html (Date of access: 03.02.2018). 2. Andreev D. Problemy razvitiya marketinga v Rossii (Problems of marketing development in Russia). Available at : http://www.marketing.spb. ru/read/essai/7.htm (Date of access: 10.02.2018). 3. Burchuladze Z. Marketingovaya deyatelnost frantsuzskih promyishlennyih kompaniy (Marketing activities of French industrial companies), Moscow, 1999. p. 24. 4. Verner K., Vays G. Chernaya kniga korporatsiy (Black Book of Corporations), Yekaterinburg. Ultra. Culture, 2007. − 416 p. 5. V chyom sekret uspehov skandinavskoy ekonomicheskoy modeli: intervyu Mihaelya Dorfmana (What is the secret of the success of the Scandinavian economic model: Michael Dorfman\'s interview). Available at : http://www.iarex.ru/interviews/18486.html (Date of access: 12.02.2018). 6. Dligach A. Ekonomicheskie i sotsialnyie peremeny: fakty, tendentsii, prognoz (Economic and social changes: facts, trends, forecast), 2013, vol. 2, pp. 141–151. 7. Dey D. Organizatsiya, orientirovannaya na ryinok: kak ponyat, privlech i uderzhat tsennyih klientov (A market-oriented organization: how to understand, attract and retain valuable customers). Moscow. Eksmo, 2008. 304 p. 8. Evropeyskaya konfederatsiya marketinga [European Confederation of Marketing]. Available at: http://emc.be/app/uploads/2017/01/EUR.EMC_.011-Marketing-2020-Survey-Dec16-v7-1.pdf (Date of access: 09.02.2018). 9. Eremchenko I. Ekonomika, finansyi i menedzhment: tendentsii i perspektivy razvitiya / Sbornik nauchnyih trudov po itogam mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii (Economics, Finance and Management: Trends and Prospects of Development / Proceedings of the International Scientific and Practical Conference). Volgograd, 2015. Vol. 2. P. 230–232. 10. Imidzh Kitaya, formiruemyiy dlya vneshnego mira (The image of China, formed for the outside world). Available at: http://www.1zam.com/41-imidzh-kitayaformiruemyj-dlya-vneshnego-mira.html (Date of access: 14.02.2018). 11. Ketova N. Lu S., Yunha K. Formirovanie i realizatsiya evroaziatskoy modeli marketinga: suschnost, imperativy, regulirovanie (Formation and implementation of the Eurasian marketing model: essence, imperatives, regulation). Rostov-on-Don: Media-Policy, 2017. 220 p. 12. Kolyada A. Marketing, kotoryiy rabotaet: sozdanie effektivnoy marketingovoy strategii v otechestvennyih usloviyah (Marketing, which works: creating an effective marketing strategy in domestic conditions). Nizhny Novgorod: Publishing house of the Business School EMAS, 2014. 240 p. 13. Kokhan O. Sotsialno-ekonomicheskoe razvitie organizatsiy i regionov Belarusi: innovatsii, sotsialnyie orientiryi, globalizatsii (Socio-economic development of organizations and regions of Belarus: innovation, social benchmarks, globalization). Vitebsk, 2009. P. 324–327. 14. Kochetkova A. Chelovecheskiy kapital i professionalnoe obrazovanie (Human Capital and Vocational Education), 2015, vol. 2, pp. 60–64. 15. Kryilova E. Menedzhment i marketing: opyit i problemyi : sbornik nauchnyih trudov (Management and marketing: experience and problems: a collection of scientific papers). Minsk: Magic Book, 2003. P. 143–146. 16. Kryilova Yu. Issledovanie ryinochnoy orientatsii rossiyskih innovatsionnyih firm (Market orientation of Russian innovation firms). Available at: http://www.cfin.ru/press/practical/2003-11/06.shtml (Date of access: 14.02.2018). 17. Maslov D., Belokorovin E. Marketolog (Marketer), 2004, vol. 10, pp. 17–25. 18. Misyura L. Marketing po-yaponski [Marketing in Japanese] // M.A.DE, 2002. No 4. Available at: http:// www.management.com.ua/marketing/mark094.html. (Date of access: 07.02.2018). 19. Nemetskaya ekonomicheskaya model: plyusyi i minusyi [The German economic model: the pros and cons] Available at : https://euroua.com/europe/eu/10874-nemetskaya-ekonomicheskaya-model-plyusy-i-minusy (Date of access: 07.02.2018). 20. Osobennosti yaponskogo marketinga [Features of Japanese marketing] Available at: http://marketing.web-3.ru (Date of access: 07.02.2018). 21. Parhimenko V. Marketing v Rossii i za rubezhom (Marketing in Russia and abroad), 2009, no. 4, pp. 63–75. 22. Perekalina N. Marketing in Russia and Abroad (Marketing v Rossii i za rubezhom), 1998, no. 2, pp. 3–14. 23. Pisareva E . Evraziyskiy Soyuz Uchenyih (Eurasian Union of Scientists), 2015, no. 2, pp. 116–118. 24. Prichinyi bankrotstva General Motors i Chrysler – oshibki v strategicheskom i operatsionnom marketing [The causes of the bankruptcy of General Motors and Chrysler - errors in the strategic and operational branding]. Available at : http://www.fortunux.ru/gm.htm (Date of access: 01.02.2018). 25. Reyting stran mira po urovnyu valovogo vnutrennego produkta (World Ranking by Level of Gross Domestic Product). Available at: http://gtmarket.ru/ratings/rating-countries-gdp/rating-countries-gdp-info (Date of access: 07.02.2018). 26. Saginova O. Izvestiya rossiyskogo ekonomicheskogo universiteta im. G.V. Plehanova (Izvestiya of the Russian Economic University named after G.V. Plekhanov), 2011, no. 3, pp. 89–106. 27. Sudzuki N. Marketing v yaponskih kompaniyah (Marketing in Japanese companies). Available at : http://www.xserver.ru/user/marjk/ (Date of access: 10.02.2018). 28. Chzhao Chzhun Shen. Praktika gorodskogo marketinga v Kitae (Practice of urban marketing in China). Beijing. Publishing House «Materials of China», 2003. 300 p. 29. Yuan Bo. Ekonomika i upravlenie (Economics and Management), 2013, no. 3, pp. 119–122. 30. Yaponskiy marketing (Japanese marketing). Available at: http://alti.ru/marketing/market-12.html (Date of access: 07.02.2018). 31. Yaponskaya assotsiatsiya marketinga. Otchet o marketinge innovatsiy v XXI st [Japanese Marketing Association. Report on the marketing of innovations in the 21st century]. Available at : http://www.jma2-jp.org/english /download/mReport.pdf (Date of access: 07.02.2018). 32. Marketing News: a publication of American Marketing Association [Marketing News: a publication of American Marketing Association]. 2003. Aug. 4. 33. Herbig P. Marketing Japanese Style [Marketing Japanese Style]. London. Quorum Books, 1995. 295 p.
Full articleComparative analysis of national marketing management systems of enterprises